The man who set fire to his father’s fiancee has a lifetime without probation

Hamilton, Ohio – the man who hit and turned on a woman on fire in Butler County in 2023 will spend the rest of her life in prison, without the possibility of probation, a judge ruled on Thursday.

Robbi Robinson She was convicted of spraying her father’s fiancee, Brenda Scott, accelerated and turning her on fire, killing her.

The jury recommended the life imprisonment without probation judgment last week, despite the fact that the death penalty was on the table in this case.

During the sentence phase, Robinson took the position with words of remorse, abandonment claims and a shocking accusation before begging the jury to forgive his life.

Get more information about the case below:

The man who set fire to his father’s fiancee has a lifetime without probation

During Robinson’s trial, prosecutors presented testimony of almost a dozen witnesses, as well as DNA, video and audio recordings, enough evidence to convince the panel of 12 men and women that Robinson planned and committed the crime.

“The State presents that the defendant, at that time, literally bottled his anger in the form of influenced fluids, put on his clothes and that the great swelling jacket in a climate of more than 70 degrees and that was when he attacked Brenda,” said Butler’s county prosecutor Katherine Pridemore, during the closing arguments last week. “It turned on fire. He inflamed the house.”

Robinson’s defense lawyers, David Brewer and Lawrence Hawkins III, decided not to present a case.

You can see Robinson’s full statement below:

Man convicted of setting fire to a woman, killing her speaks before the sentence

“We had no questions for most witnesses. That will be the subject here in the final argument, okay?” Brewer told the jury during the final arguments last week. “There are facts: facts and evidence. There are interpretations of these facts and there are arguments. There are plans to give those facts and those interpretations and arguments on a later date. What we want is that this part of this case ends and, as such, we have nothing more at this point.”

The defense focused on the sentence phase, calling three of Robinson’s family members to the stand, as well as a forensic psychologist who evaluated Robinson during his time and believes that he has a borderline personality disorder.

Before Robinson gave his statement, his sister and mother minors testified that they advocate for the jury’s clemency. The first, Tsaria Robinson, told the jury that he loved his brother and that he did not want the death penalty.

Renee Robinson echoed her daughter’s plea, but shared more with the jury. She described her youngest son as a sweet child who “would not hurt a fly.” She said Robinson was loved and attended and had a close relationship with her brothers and Tsaria as a child.

Renee said his marriage problems with his father, Robbi Robinson Mr., negatively hit his son. Robinson bounced between his place and his father’s house in the years before the 2023 incident, but Renee said that her separate husband began to distance himself from Robinson.

Renee told the jury that he believes that his son has mental health problems and that he feels that he failed him, not seeing the “red flags.” Robinson witnessed several violent family interactions as a child for which he never received advice. She said she does not believe that her son deserves the death penalty and hopes they give her life with the possibility of probation.

During his supplication of almost 10 minutes, Robinson refuted the image of a loving home life that his mother painted the jury. In addition to his love for Tsaria, Robinson said he felt neglected by his family.

“I would like my family to spend more time with me. I feel that they abandoned me and I felt only for a long time. I have been in jail since May 11, 2023, almost two years. I have spoken with two of my family members by phone. 99% of her went with my mother and some of that was with my little sister, but I have not come to anyone in which I have not come to any family.

Robinson’s family members left the courtroom when he sat in the witness post.

“I would like to have a connection with my brothers. My mother was up here saying that it was a good connection. I never had a good connection with them,” Robinson said. “They had a problem with my father and they took it out and left me alone. Because I have nothing to do with my father or their relationship with them … You know my father was not a good man for me. He was simply not a good man.”

During his testimony, Renee said that while she was disappointed with how she treated her son in recent years, Robinson Mr. was a good father for her children when they grew up. Renee also said that she and other family members tried to visit Robinson in jail, but he didn’t want them to do it because it was “too difficult for him.”

Robinson maintained an almost boring and indifferent appearance during his trial for murder, often tilting his head in his hand and sharing some words with his lawyers. On the stand, he apologized to the jury and Scott’s family.

“I made a bad decision, but I’m not a bad person. I’m sorry for Brenda Scott’s family. I know it’s difficult, but you can find her at the bottom of your hearts to forgive me, I’m sorry … even if I could exchange my own life to bring (Scott) I would do it. I would really do it from the bottom of my heart,” Robinson said. “I know that I have to be punished and assume the responsibility of my actions. Sorry. Please, sorry my life. Please give me a prayer of life. All I want is to see my little sister again, even if 25, 35, 45, 50 years are needed. All I want is to see my little sister and share moments with her.”

Robinson also made an accusation never heard in the case. Prosecutors could not interrogate him because he was not under oath, but Robinson’s claim was not backed by any evidence presented during the trial.

“In May 2023, I was not happy. I was not happy with my family. I was not happy with my life situation. I was not happy that Brenda was having a sexual relationship with me and I was not really happy and I reacted,” Robinson said. “I regretted instantly. That’s why I tried to turn off the fire with the extinguisher.”